May 22, 2023

About That Earnings Apocalypse

Weekly Market Commentary

Some investors were bracing for an earnings apocalypse. Once again, fears were exaggerated.

It’s not the first time some have been expecting dire results. A CNBC story six months ago previewing Q3 profits suggested earnings could disappoint in a big way. They didn’t.

Why wasn’t there a letdown in Q1? Let’s look at a couple of possibilities.

First, analysts have traditionally been too cautious with their corporate earnings forecasts. Q1 was no exception. Usually, analysts lower their numbers too much as firms gear up to report and firms step over a low hurdle.

Second, we’re not in a recession. Fortune 500 companies are huge. They may execute well and expand their reach. Or conditions in their industry may be more robust than the overall economy, and they benefit.

But they aren’t immune to missteps. If they fail to execute, it can be reflected in disappointing sales and profits.

But because these firms are so big, most aren’t immune to the tailwinds and headwinds that an economic expansion or recession will bring. If folks are spending, they are typically the recipients. If folks are stingy, they feel the pain.

With 94% of S&P 500 firms having reported in Q1, earnings are projected to fall by just 0.2% versus one year ago per Refintiv. On an absolute basis, it’s not impressive.

But analysts had been expecting profits to decline by over 5% back on April 1. In other words, it’s a sizable beat.

Why do we care? Over a longer period, profits play a big role in the direction of stock prices.

Looking at Q1, it boils down to modest overall economic growth and expectations that were too gloomy.

If we slip into a recession, we’d probably expect profits to decline by roughly 10 – 20%, though it would depend on how shallow or deep any recession might be.

Currently, analysts aren’t pricing a recession into their forecasts. Why? The outlook is murky, but there aren’t any concrete signs that the economy is about to contract.

S&P 500 profits versus one year ago

2022 Q1 ‘Q2 ‘Q3 ‘Q4 2023 Q1 ‘Q2 ‘Q3 ‘Q4
11.4% 8.4% 4.4% -3.2% -0.2% -5.7% 1.2% 9.2%

Source: Refinitiv
2023 Q1 projection through 5/19/2023, with 94% of S&P 500 firms having reported 2023 Q1 results.
2022 Q2, 2023 Q3, 2023 Q4 are forecasts as of 5/19/2023.
Forecasts are subject to change.

Notably, analysts are expecting record earnings in Q3 and Q4. That’s far from recessionary. But six to nine months out in earnings land is almost an eternity.

Let’s take those estimates with a couple of grains of salt. It wouldn’t be a surprise if the projections were tweaked in response to company-issued forecasts and changes in the economy.

Reproduction Prohibited without Express Permission. Copyright FDP Wealth Management. All rights reserved. Advisory Services offered through FDP Wealth Management, LLC, a state Registered Investment Advisor. Securities offered through Valmark Securities, Inc., Member FINRA/SIPC | 130 Springside Drive Suite 300 Akron, OH 44333-2431 | 800.765.5201. FDP Wealth Management, LLC is a separate entity from Valmark Securities, Inc. If you do not want to receive further editions of this weekly newsletter, please contact me at (949) 855-4337 or e-mail me at info@fdpwm.com or write me at 8841 Research Drive, Suite 100, Irvine, CA 92618. FDP Wealth Management, LLC, Valmark Securities, Inc. and their representatives do not offer tax or legal advice. You should consult your tax or legal professional regarding your individual circumstances. Indices are unmanaged and cannot be invested directly in. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

RELATED POSTS

An Annual Ritual at the Gas Pump

You’re right if you have this nagging feeling that gas prices rise in the spring. As the graphic illustrates, on average prices rise through Memorial Day, plateau over the summer, and slip in the fall. This year is no exception, as prices echo the seasonal pattern.

Rate Cuts Still on the Table, Timing Less Certain

We often discuss the Federal Reserve and interest rates because both greatly impact investors. For starters, changes in interest rates have a significant impact on stock prices and income earned on savings. Sharply higher rates in 2022 pushed equities into a bear market.

Just Do It

That ubiquitous phrase from one of America’s most extensive athletic footwear and apparel makers seems to have been adopted by most American shoppers. The U.S. Census Bureau reported last week that retail sales jumped 0.7% in March, following a strong 0.9% rise in February.

The Road to Lower Inflation Takes a Detour

The rate of inflation is accelerating. That’s not how we hoped to start this week’s Insights. Take a moment and review Figure 1. The 4-month moving average has broken out of its long-term downward trend (red-dashed lines). On a monthly basis, prices bottomed in June and began to gradually turn higher. The upward trajectory picked up in January.

No Matter How You Slice It and Dice It…

The latest employment numbers from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) point to a robust job market. On Friday, the U.S. BLS reported that nonfarm payrolls rose 303,000 in March, well ahead of expectations. It’s not simply March; growth has been above 250,000 for four months running.